YouTube Icon

Google AMP in 2020 - better, but still not good

Google AMP in 2020 - better, but still not good

Accelerated Mobile Pages (AMP for short) is an innovation presented by Google in late 2015. In case you're a web designer, you've presumably effectively known about it. Since the time its presentation, the innovation vowed to make making performant versatile amicable website pages simpler and progressively charming. Be that as it may, with a significant reaction for the engineer network, it hasn't arrived at the degree of endorsement that I think it was expected to - in any event not without a ton of debate. 

What's AMP? 

We should begin with a more top to bottom clarification of what AMP truly is and how it functions. 

As a rule, AMP is an open-source Web Component structure. Web Components itself is a lot of various advances empowering designers to make local, reusable parts, motivated by however not bound to any JS structure. 


AMP expands upon this innovation to give you a lot of streamlined segments for simpler improvement of performant sites. In any case, it's not your regular part library you may be familiar with. That is on the grounds that, while giving you these segments, AMP additionally confines the utilization of custom JavaScript code and constrains your standard CSS and HTML capacities. 

Nonetheless, it's JavaScript that is the most restricted in AMP. Recently it got conceivable to utilize a restricted arrangement of JS functionalities inside AMP pages. Yet at the same time, the go-to method of utilizing any modestly propelled custom JS code stays to be a <iframe>, or should I say <amp-iframe> which additionally accompanies its own arrangement of restrictions. 

Due to all that, AMP is most appropriate for genuinely straightforward, text-substantial distributions like websites or news sources and that is the place it's seen the most reception. 

AMP Cache 

Because of every one of these restrictions, AMP sites can be very quick. However, there's as yet one increasingly mystery to their presentation. All things considered, AMP or not - a site is a site and there's no unique in-program improvement that could make them any quicker. No, the mystery is AMP Cache. 

AMP Cache is an intermediary like Content Delivery Network (CDN) that is intended to serve just substantial AMP pages. Most striking AMP Cache suppliers are Google and Bing, whose servers because of their sheer size and figuring power, can convey AMP pages to clients around the globe blazingly quick. 

AMP encounters 

In spite of the fact that in this post I talk generally about AMP sites which are the principle part of the AMP biological system, there are different sorts of encounters that AMP bolsters. These are AMP stories (fast slideshow-like encounters), AMP promotions (for making AMP-good "client centered" advertisements), and AMP email (for rich AMP-based messages). 

Designers' issues 

Presently, with this short outline of AMP and conceivably your own encounters with the innovation, I figure you would already be able to see probably a portion of the reasons why such huge numbers of engineers are against AMP. 

Absence of adaptability 

As a result of the considerable number of confinements that AMP puts on your structure, it very well may be fairly difficult to utilize it to make the site you'd really need. Despite the fact that AMP parts can regularly accelerate the advancement of specific highlights and CSS is all you have to alter the majority of the site's components, numerous AMP pages (particularly those created naturally by for example a WordPress module) can come up short on the inclination that is so extraordinary to a given site or brand. 

Muddled execution benefits 

Despite the fact that AMP is obviously centered around portable and speed, the presentation benefits it gives aren't ensured. It's no puzzle that a great deal of AMP's exhibition edge originates from the utilization of AMP Cache. On the off chance that your AMP site isn't qualified for storing or is gotten to straightforwardly from your own servers rather than the reserve, you may encounter no presentation gains by any stretch of the imagination! 

As a general rule, it's extremely hard if certainly feasible for an AMP page with all its to some degree massive Web Components and without AMP Cache or Google's shrewd pre-associate stunts to come anyplace near hand-tuned site. 

Google's strength 

The last and most likely the greatest concern engineers had against AMP is Google's impact. 

Despite the fact that AMP is an open-source activity, it was begun by Google and it's Google who stands to pick up the most from it. It's unmistakably obvious in Google's push towards AMP and the manner in which they treat the innovation. 

AMP holds an exceptionally unique spot in many Google administrations, which, as we probably am aware, are one of the significant wellsprings of traffic for some sites. Google frequently favors AMP pages on its essential query items page, in Google Discover, and different administrations. AMP stories - similar ones I've discussed before - additionally get unique treatment in type of a situation at the top news merry go round that is regularly found in indexed lists. 

Actually, Google says that they organize pages in query items by performance(among content and different components) and that an all around streamlined site can get comparable outcomes. What's more, since AMP pages are "quick as a matter of course" they get this extraordinary treatment practically out-of-the-container. In any case, I've just disclosed to you that it's just the situation when AMP gets reserved - and I guarantee all of you pages that Google shows are stored. Entertainingly however, that is one more body of evidence to be made against AMP. 

AMP Cache is no enchantment - it's only an exceptionally quick reserving component - and that is it. Be that as it may, such a reserve doesn't work completely straightforwardly. At whatever point the client gets to your AMP page stored for example by Google, rather than your area and legitimate URL, they'll see Google's in their URL bar. Your area may just be obvious in an extra dim bar underneath the best possible URL one. 

Numerous individuals concur that this cutoff points brand acknowledgment. It's likewise a wellspring of numerous issues identified with what URL to utilize when sharing (in spite of the fact that it currently utilizes the first URL in many programs, etc. 

Ongoing upgrades 

These issues may cause AMP to appear to be terrible, however in truth... better believe it sort of is. Without a doubt, possibly its open objective of better and quicker Web encounters for the clients is acceptable, yet the usage is presently "meh, best case scenario. 

Be that as it may, AMP has come a really long path since its presentation and numerous progressions have been made to improve it for engineers and clients the same. It's as yet insufficient without a doubt - but rather these are positive developments. 

Administration changes 

I won't be going a lot into subtleties here. For the most part, the fundamental remove is that AMP since the time late 2018 is under another, progressively open administration model. It's surely some portion of a push to guide AMP away from negative "Google disgrace", and more into a genuine open-source theory. 

In light of the change improvement of AMP is presently in charge of the Technical Steering Committee (TSC) made out of different distributers who use AMP. 

JavaScript remittance 

Like I've referenced before, JavaScript has just decently as of late been permitted to run on AMP pages (outside of the <amp-iframe> that is). It's conceivable gratitude to <amp-script> Web Component that executes the gave JavaScript in a unique Web Worker-based condition with virtual DOM, without hindering the primary string. 

In spite of the fact that this methodology sounds promising, recall that Web Workers don't approach DOM, and therefore, such execution requires custom taking care of for the entirety of the JS DOM API strategies. Because of this prerequisite, just a bunch of generally essential and normal techniques is actualized. Also, in exemplary AMP style, the size of the JS code is restricted to 10 KB for each <amp-script> with a sum of 150 KB permitted. 

The absence of custom JavaScript in AMP pages, albeit truly constraining has been one of the key fixings answerable for making AMP quick. Yet at this point, with the presentation of <amp-script> some began to question if it's the correct way. In principle, the Web Worker usage is lined up with AMP's objectives, yet from one hand - it's as yet custom JS - and from the other - it's still excessively restricting for cutting edge use. 

URL changes 

Outside of the AMP itself, Google has additionally made a few stages to make the venture all the more engaging. Seemingly the greatest change here is the presentation of Signed HTTP Exchanges (SXGs). It's an element that permits accurately set up and checked areas to show their unique space in the URL bar, regardless of whether it's gotten to through AMP Cache. 

Genuinely, it's a positive development. Be that as it may, right now, it's very defective. Setting up SXGs yourself can be lumbering, and the main other route is to utilize a specialist co-op, which - in any event for the present - implies Cloudflare AMP Real URL as it were. 

Additionally, to work effectively, SXGs must be bolstered on the program side also. Accordingly, low cross-program support is one more issue as just the most recent Chromium-based programs bolster it. Presumably the most remarkable avoidance is all the iOS-based cell phones. 

Individual experience 

To reveal to you something about my own involvement in AMP, I tried it. Indeed, I initially needed to overhaul this entire blog with AMP bolster worked in. 

To be completely forthright, the advancement experience wasn't generally that terrible - particularly with Ghost's help for AMP. Numerous highlights were extremely simple to actualize with AMP segments. In any case, the absence of highlight full JavaScript bolster was a major issue. 

The two most significant bits of custom JavaScript on my blog are the remark area and the promotion that keeps everything running. While the remark segment was to some degree simple to place into <amp-iframe> (despite the fact that it felt pointlessly convoluted and hacky), the promotion was definitely not. Without a doubt, I could put it inside the <amp-iframe>, yet the issue is that AMP restricts such practice. Just a bunch of perfect advertisement systems are upheld through the devoted <amp-ad> part. Furthermore, tragically, Carbon Adswhich serve designer agreeable promotions here on my blog - isn't one of them. 

In this manner, I wound up hand-tuning my site, accomplishing preferable execution over AMP - with or without AMP Cache. 


Along these lines, to sum up everything, AMP is a truly intriguing thought in light of some incredible objectives for making the Web a superior spot. In any case, the execution entangles everything so gravely.

Author Biography.


CrowdforThink is the leading Indian media platform, known for its end-to-end coverage of the Indian startups through news, reports, technology and inspiring stories of startup founders, entrepreneurs, investors, influencers and analysis of the startup eco-system, mobile app developers and more dedicated to promote the startup ecosystem.

Join Our Newsletter.

Subscribe to CrowdforThink newsletter to get daily update directly deliver into your inbox.

CrowdforGeeks is where lifelong learners come to learn the skills they need, to land the jobs they want, to build the lives they deserve.


CrowdforThink is a leading Indian media and information platform, known for its end-to-end coverage of the Indian startup ecosystem.


Our mission is "Har Koi Dekhe Video, Har Ghar Dekhe Video, Ghar Ghar Dekhe Video" so we Provide videos related to Tutorials, Travel, Technology, Wedding, Cooking, Dance, Festivals, Celebration.

Apna Video Wala

News & Blogs


Top 5 Trends in Software Development

2023 will see significant changes in the corporate environment as a result of unprecedentedly hig...


Gusto Payroll App, Should You Clone It?

When it comes to payroll management, there are only a few platforms as popular as Gusto Payroll a...


Top Factors to Consider While Selecting an Idea...

In today's rapidly evolving digital landscape, cloud computing has become an essential compon...

Top Authors

Lamia Rochdi is the Marketing Manager at Bell Flavors & Fragrances EMEA. A successful family-...

Lamia Rochdi

I’m Mertin Wilson a technician in a camera company and certified expert of different P...

Mertin Wilson

Zakariya has recently joined the PakWheels team as a Content Marketing Executive, shortly after g...

Zakariya Usman

Pankaj Singh is a Senior Digital Marketing Consultant with more than 2 years of experience in SEO...

Pankaj Singh

Our Client Says

WhatsApp Chat with Our Support Team